Living in the Past – Stalin v Lenin
COMMENT: Hello,
I reside in Finland/Helsinki. The Soviet Union attacked Finland in 1939, Stalin was one who organized a false flag in Manila. Lots of Finnish troopers and civilians died. However we survived. We Finnish folks know Russians extraordinarily nicely. It’s a historic undeniable fact that Russians at all times prepare false flags and attempt to slave different nations and other people. And that’s occurring simply now in Ukraine. Putin attacked Ukraine and he’s attempting to slave Ukraine.
Finest Regards from Finland
JT
REPLY: You will need to not choose a rustic by its leaders. There are at all times left and proper in each nation and no nation enjoys 100% approval of its folks. Simply have a look at america. There are ONLY three presidents who received with 60% or extra, FDR 1st time period, Johnson following Kennedy’s assassination, and Richard Nixon who promised to finish Vietnam. All others received with only a few factors over 50%. Within the 2008 Election of Obama v McCain rating his victory with simply 52.9%. Even Lenin warned to not put Stalin in cost.
It’s fallacious to guage Russia by Stalin and as we speak the powers that be simply hate the Russian folks and attribute all the things to Putin. It’s important to additionally perceive that there’s a left and a proper in Russia that also prevails as we speak and Putin is a reasonable that if ignored by the West, will drive Russia into the fingers of the acute proper.
We MUST perceive historical past for there has at all times been a query of the place Russia begins and ends and who constitutes the Russian folks. These questions have been debated by Russian thinkers themselves for hundreds of years post-Russian Revolution which ended greater than 300 years of tsarist rule. Imagine it or not, Putin is NOT attempting to resurrect the Soviet Union for that was not even the imaginative and prescient of Lenin – however Stalin.
At first, Lenin was revered because the architect of the brand new Russia. He was the elder statesman of the Bolshevik revolution. Stalin, alternatively, was what we’d name a Neocon. He was the formidable social gathering chief with visions of absolute authoritarian management. The 2 clashed not solely over their political imaginative and prescient for Russia but additionally on a really private degree hurling insults steeped in grudges. It was this battle that truly proved to be an excessive amount of for Lenin leading to his untimely demise.
The battle between these two Russian leaders reached a climax within the final days of December 1922. That is when 2,000 delegates from all around the former Russian empire gathered collectively in Moscow to create a brand new state which might turn into the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. The imaginative and prescient of this new state was starkly totally different between the 2 males. There have been republics of Ukraine, Belarus, and Transcaucasia, which have been formally unbiased of Russia. When Georgy Chicherin, the Soviet Russian commissar for international relations, signed the treaty with Germany the place every surrendered their claims in opposition to the opposite for battle reparations in July 1918, there was an issue of unity. Ukraine and Belarus have been unbiased earlier than 1919 however have been then overrun by the Bolsheviks in 1919. They’d objected to forgiving Germany.
Ukraine and Belarus took the place that the Russian authorities had no proper to talk on behalf of Ukrainian and Belarus. In Georgia, there too they objected insisting that their rights because the members of an unbiased republic have been violated. That is was in the end set in movement the start of the ultimate model of the Soviet Union.
It was in August of 1922 when Joseph Stalin created a particular fee to suggest a brand new political mannequin of relations between the communist Get together’s Central Committee, Russia and the republics. Stalin’s proposal was known as the “autonomization of the republics” whereby the formally unbiased republics can be included into the Russian Soviet Federation with rights of autonomy. Nonetheless, the Russian Federation would turn into the central authority subordinating the formally unbiased republics. This resulted in a rebel with the Georgians led the revolt in opposition to Stalin’s mannequin. They have been joined by the Ukrainians and Belarusians.
This battle between Lenin’s imaginative and prescient of a union extra akin to america mannequin and Lenin’s imaginative and prescient of absolute central energy resulted within the heated dialog with Feliks Dzerzhinsky, who was the pinnacle of the key police and a supporter of Stalin. Stalin and plenty of of his supporters, comparable to Ordzhonikidze and Dzerzhinsky, have been really non-Russians. Stalin was Georgian and Dzerzhinsky was actiually Polish. Apparently, Felix Dzerzhinsky was remembered in St Petersburg on a Commemorative plaque devoted him.
However the stroke prevented him from taking any decisive steps in opposition to them. Two days later, a fee of social gathering officers, led by Stalin, positioned strict limitations on Lenin’s actions, successfully isolating him. They mentioned the restrictions have been designed to stop the worsening of Lenin’s well being. However in addition they served a political goal.
Lenin couldn’t attend the congress and he actually didn’t belief Stalin. Consequently, the paralyzed Lenin dictated his well-known ideas on the nationality query in a doc he despatched to the social gathering management. It was a letter titled “On the Query of Nationalities or ‘Autonomization.’” On December 31st, 1922, he attacked Stalin’s insurance policies criticizing the rights supplied to the republics by the Union treaty, deeming them insufficient to cease the rise of Nice Russian nationalism. Lenin known as this risk as “great-power chauvinism.” To Lenin noticed these folks as non-Russians who he didn’t belief and feared for the way forward for the Russian folks.
In Lenin believed that Stalin, who was not Russia, posed a serious risk to Russia. He considered Stalin’s dream of the united states as a risk to the unity of state which he was appropriate. Lenin’s concept of a union of unbiased states can be sustained by native autonomy taking into consideration their native customes. Lenin was ready to switch the Union he had initially proposed with a looser affiliation of states with the centralized powers to be confined to issues of protection and worldwide relations solely. Lenin additionally maintained that the republics ought to retain the fitting of secession to stop Stalin’s central dominance of authority.
I extremely suggest watching the film Mr. Jones. Whereas it will NOT present the battle between Lenin and Stalin, it should present the ruthlessness of Stalin that Lenin feared. However Stalin was NOT a Russian, however he has tarnish the fame of all Russians ever since. It’s ironic that Stalin was a Georgian, which is within the Caucuses bordering Turkey the place they hate Russians for the very oppression of Stalin.
So, as you may see, this can be a very complicated topic. Putin is just not a follower of Stalin wheras different behind him are. So we needs to be very care what we want for in relation to Regime Change. Simply perhaps they know this as nicely and need Regime Change to make sure battle. Very attention-grabbing certainly. We should always NOT choose Putin by Stalin or all Russians for that matter. That’s the propaganda of the Neocons who’re nonetheless combating in opposition to Stalin.
The submit Residing within the Previous – Stalin v Lenin first appeared on Armstrong Economics.
